Why not subscribe?

Friday, November 17, 2006

Ask not what your country ... just don't ask

I've never really been a Kennedy fan. It seemed the Kennedys had style, but not much substance. But there was that ability to turn a phrase. But in the NYT's obituary of Milton Friedman, we see that Friedman turned one of JFK's best known phrases inside-out in an interesting way:

"In 1962, Mr. Friedman took on President John F. Kennedy’s popular inaugural exhortation: “Ask not what your country can do for you. Ask what you can do for your country.” In an introduction to his classic book “Capitalism and Freedom,” a collection of his writings and lectures, he said President Kennedy had got it wrong: You should ask neither.

“What your country can do for you,” Mr. Friedman said, implies that the government is the patron, the citizen the ward; and “what you can do for your country” assumes that the government is the master, the citizen the servant. Rather, he said, you should ask, “What I and my compatriots can do through government to help discharge our individual responsibilities, to achieve our several goals and purposes, and above all protect our freedom.”



  1. Hay Saw You in 2000 Bloggers

    Think American Idol meets Survivor with The Apprentice. Who gets voted off the island? Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down? Hired or fired? Do you Digg it? Use reality tv groundrules, and VOTE!

    Hotel @nyware is paying the 2000 bloggers off in social currency. This is an open source call out there to vet out the 2000 to Hotel @nyware's new Z list of 150.
    2000 Bloggers-Idol meets Survivor with Apprentice: Vote some off the island!

    The @List Blogroll(It's like a Z list, only different)

  2. I don't get what ed reif's point was but, I now have less severance for Kennedy's one famous line.Hyrum Berg